Skip to content

Ground Zero and Reasons to Hope

August 27, 2010

Cyanide and Happiness, a daily webcomic

The Ground Zero Mosque. We couldn’t avoid the topic forever, so let’s talk about it. Unless you are like my 15-year-old brother (‘Eh?’), you will have heard about it, furore and all. At this point, whenever I hear the phrase, I turn around to whoever it is and with the exaggerated patience reserved for imbeciles, I tell them, ‘it’s not at Ground Zero, and it’s not a mosque. Now be quiet.’

Actually, I don’t add the last sentence, but I wish I could.

Seriously, I am like an internet-magpie. I see a link, and I click on it, and down the rabbit hole vortex I go, clicking link after link, collecting article after article, getting angrier and angrier with all of the insane comments I have the idiocy to read. It’s an ugly world out there.

Astonishing is, that in the guise of open-mindedness and exercising their First Amendment rights*, and despite the denunciations and denials from vituperative commentators and right-wing nutters, concerned citizens and still-grieving victims, all insist that nobody had a problem with a mosque existing per se, they just have a problem with it existing anywhere near Ground Zero, and possibly in fact anywhere in Lower Manhattan – in fact, scratch that, not in NYC, okay? Because that’s just insensitive.**

Truth be told, a mosque anywhere in the US just makes all of us  bigoted idiots plain uncomfortable.

Apart from it being the most ludicrous and spurious connection (and I rather think it’s more sacrilegious to have a McDonald’s in the same city as Ground Zero) – that having a Muslim place of worship is a smirking ‘screw you’ to the American public**** –  it seems to have brought out all the haters and united them, right wing and left, giving them a free ticket to express all the loathing, suspicion, prejudice and fear – yes, fear – that they harbour towards a community of their fellow Americans. This is all the more strange when you consider how Being American is quite a big deal to Americans, and it seems badly inconsonant with all the values that are meant to define what Being American is.

Ugliest of all, and not surprising to me in the least, was the news that this wasn’t as isolated a cause as people would like to believe. It happens across the US – and the UK, too, let’s not be exclusive – without the excuse of Ground Zero being a few blocks away, legitimising hatred and giving voice to a sentiment that has always existed – as such sentiments do in some form or other – running counter-current to all our ideas of englightenment. So far, it has been taboo to admit them because it paints you as a hater, and a dangerous one. But it’s okay now. Enough ‘important’ people are doing it as to make the rest of us think it’s okay to trash Muslims or Martians or Mormons or Mohicans or Marsupials or anyone else enough people have accumulated enough vitriol against.

And frankly, we could talk about people being stupid all day.† But that actually isn’t why I began writing this – no, really. I have ranted (MILDLY) for several paragraphs, but the real reason was this:

In St Charles County, Missouri, a church opens its doors every week for Muslims to do the Friday Jum’ah Prayer.

And they don’t have to do that, but they do. And this is the perfect antidote for every negative article and poorly-articulated opinion I have read, and every blow my faith in humanity†† took.

‘Khan, who owns three gas stations, said most people in St. Charles County are “open-hearted and humble”.’

And I think Mr Khan has hit on something very vital: it isn’t so much important to be open-minded as to be open-hearted. We pride ourselves – rather too much††† – on our openmindedness and consider it a measure of our liberality, but you can be so open-minded your brain falls out. And that’s not nice, when there’s so much ‘open’ that there’s no ‘mind’. Don’t do that. Put your brain back and open your heart, because we’re all human, and while we have differences intellectual, theological and thaumaturgical, nothing changes the humanity we have in common.

* Up until a few weeks ago, I didn’t even know what the heck the First Amendment actually WAS. Oh I had HEARD of it, but that’s like you’ve heard of the Easter Bunny.
** Out of interest, do planes still fly over NYC? Because I think that’s pretty insensitive,*** too. PTSD is real, people.
*** Also, I think it’s a moral outrage that skyscrapers still exist anywhere in the US. It’s cold, man. All of the 9/11 victims and their families and friends and ethnic neighbours frown upon your tall buildings.
**** cf. ‘Please forgive me for the actions of extremists I have never met who commit acts of violence that I have never advocated’, and to give that some balance, from the same author: Not in our town: what happens when meanness wins.
Not sure if that means talking all day about people being stupid, or talking about people who are stupid all day. MAYBE BOTH.
It must be added that I don’t have a great deal of faith in humanity.
† i.e. ‘I am so openminded I have one black friend!’
‘Well I’M so openminded I have a black friend who is MILDLY JEWISH, BEAT THAT SCUM’
‘I’m so openminded my black friend is a HALF-CASTE GAY ALBINO RASTAFARIAN who smokes WEED and is POOR and is a CLICHE OMG SO BEAT THAT, NEGRO.’
Etc.

The Rock Pool has survived SIX MONTHS and a HUNDRED POSTS, and we are celebrating by giving away a picture-book of a different kind: read an interview with the author, Gwynneth Beasley, hosted by our own lovely Maryam.

Advertisements
10 Comments leave one →
  1. ShadowsDawn permalink
    August 27, 2010 3:12 pm

    I thought this was quite good on the subject.

    http://www.cracked.com/blog/3-reasons-the-ground-zero-mosque-debate-makes-no-sense/

    • August 27, 2010 3:16 pm

      Oh, I’ve read it – thanks! I realised I couldn’t link every stupid or smart thing I read, so I didn’t link any of them 😄

  2. August 27, 2010 3:37 pm

    amen, saya. i mean ameen.

  3. Kaimalino permalink
    August 27, 2010 4:20 pm

    Short response: Amen!
    Long response:
    No, not the marsupials!
    Seriously, it’s the grossly inaccurate Nazi metaphors that have given me the most indigestion. No, it is not like building a monument to Hitler at Auschwitz, one clear-thinking friend ranted with me. It’s like building a YMCA at a Burlington Coat Factory. Nope, scratch that, he said–a YMIA, if there is such a thing.
    I have hardly been able to sleep while mentally lamenting over all this misplaced anger. I wonder what the Pilgrims would think, but maybe they were right-wing nutters, too, in spite of their opression. Even some friends of my own faith have been possessed by idiocy of late–my Facebook contact list is about to undergo some culling, so I don’t suffer from insomnia indefinitely.
    One of the LDS Articles of Faith is “We claim the privilege of worshiping Almighty God according to the dictates of our own conscience, and allow all men the same privilege, let them worship how, where, or what they may.”
    It’s a relief to hear some folks actually act like they believe that.

    (BTW, as a point of interest, the resident two-year-old adores your Muslim Xtremists. “Guys! Guys wear hats! Ha! Want hat! More guys! Guys play! Ha! Guys play with me?” Also, I want to pat your brother on the head, if it wouldn’t make him punch me.)

  4. Allumer permalink
    August 27, 2010 4:50 pm

    Er, I could avoid this idiotic topic indefinitely. America! Make up your mind, which brown people are you threatened by the most? The “illegal aliens” or the “Mozlems?”

    And Kaimalino, you took the words right out of my mouth: Not the Marsupials!

  5. August 27, 2010 6:20 pm

    The marsupials are dangerous, guys. They can be hiding anything in those pouches, like BOMBS or – gasp – BABIES.

    Perhaps similar to the LDS doctrine is the Qur’an’s ‘there is no compulsion in deen’, where ‘deen’ means roughly a way of life (including but not limited to religion or faith). And similar, too, perhaps, to the spirit and purpose of the First Amendment.

    Funnily, the more oppressed you are, the more nutty you get, if history and current affairs are anything to go by. But hey, that’s not anything common sense couldn’t tell us – we just call it ‘radicalisation’ now. It reminds me of that NS article I linked Rivenheart to, here: http://www.newscientist.com/article/mg20727684.700-you-cant-fight-violence-with-violence.html

    I’ll swap with you my 15-year-old for your 2-year-old! He’s not the punching type, he’s the point-and-laugh/duck-and-run type, so he’ll duck and run as you try to pat him, and then he’ll point and laugh.

    Allumer, what about the illegal alien Mozlems from Mars with marsupials tendencies?

    Maryam, I read your comment and went ‘lol’ in my head, but thought that was too brainless to type. But you see that doesn’t stop me.

  6. Mahfooz permalink
    August 27, 2010 9:05 pm

    Great article. I tend to read an article, head down to the comments section, read a few and get so angry that I close the whole window. Didn’t realise that people could be so narrow-minded, and blindly believe everything that the media tells them. It is shocking that people are so filled with hatred that is based on nothing but misconceptions and ignorance.

    • August 28, 2010 6:15 pm

      Oh I don’t read a few. I read them all. Every last one. And I get so angry I keep the tab open in my browser for weeks until I get around to finishing them.

      Except then I don’t, and then weeks later I realise if I don’t close some tabs, Firefox will die, so then I close them, having forgotten what made me so furious in the first place.

  7. August 28, 2010 11:53 pm

    I LOVE YOU.

    Have I mentioned that lately? Cause yeah. You are…some sanity in the midst of this mess is a good thing.

Trackbacks

  1. As The Ashes Fall «

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: